Gold or silver nisab?
Two thresholds that were once worth the same, and are far apart today.
The nisab is the threshold below which no zakat is due: twenty mithqal of gold, or two hundred dirhams of silver. When the nisab was set, the two were worth about the same. Today they aren’t, and which one you measure against can decide whether you pay.
The weights
| According to | Gold | Silver |
|---|---|---|
| AAOIFI Standard 35 (3/2/2) | 85 g | 595 g |
| The National Zakat Foundation and Islamic Relief | 87.48 g | 612.36 g |
| Diyanet (Türkiye) | 80.18 g | 561 g, from its hadith commentary |
The differences come from how the old weights are converted to grams. They move the threshold by up to 9%. The choice between gold and silver moves it many times over. Diyanet’s High Board measures against gold; the silver weight comes from Diyanet’s hadith commentary.
What it means in money
With gold at €110 a gram and silver at €1.30, the gold nisab is €9,350 and the silver nisab €773.50. Someone with €3,000 in savings is below the first and far above the second: nothing is due against gold, €75 against silver.
Who says what
- AAOIFI measures money and trade goods against gold (3/2/2).
- Diyanet measures against 80.18 g of gold.
- The National Zakat Foundation advises silver when you own more than gold alone, as safer and better for those who receive zakat, and gold when gold is all you have.
- Islamic Relief says most scholars advise silver because it is lower, calls either one valid, and says gold must be used when gold is all you have, and silver when silver is.
What Zakat354 does
The calculator starts with gold and lets you switch. When you are above one threshold and below the other, the result says what would be due with the other metal, so the choice is never made for you without your seeing it. If gold is all you hold that counts, it is measured against gold whichever you chose, and silver alone against silver.